A recent investigation by the BBC has unveiled allegations that energy giant Shell has ignored repeated warnings regarding a controversial clean-up initiative for oil-polluted regions in southern Nigeria. The multinational company, headquartered in London, in collaboration with the Nigerian government, has maintained that the ongoing clean-up efforts in Ogoniland have been successful over the past eight years. However, evidence uncovered by the BBC suggests that the project, funded by various oil companies to the sum of $1 billion, has encountered numerous issues despite repeated warnings.
Critics have described the clean-up operation as a “con” and a “scam,” asserting that the project has squandered funds while failing to mitigate the devastating effects of oil pollution in Ogoniland. Residents in the Niger Delta region continue to endure the consequences of oil contamination, even 13 years after a pivotal UN report shed light on their plight.
Shell responded to the BBC’s inquiries by stating, “The operating conditions in the Niger Delta remain challenging due to widespread illegal activities like oil theft. In the event of spills from our facilities, we undertake clean-up and remediation efforts, regardless of the cause. Furthermore, for operational spills, we provide compensation to affected individuals and communities.”
These revelations come as a civil trial is set to commence at the High Court in London, where legal representatives for two Ogoniland communities will argue that Shell bears responsibility for oil pollution spanning from 1989 to 2020, allegedly originating from its infrastructure. The impacted communities claim that the spills have deprived them of clean water, hindered farming and fishing activities, and posed significant health risks to the public.
While Shell has refuted any wrongdoing and attributed spills to sabotage, theft, and illicit refining activities, the company faces mounting pressure from affected communities seeking accountability for the environmental damage. The BBC visited the areas in the Niger Delta impacted by oil spills, revealing the toll on families and their livelihoods.
Grace Audi, a resident of Ogale, shared her challenges of living with contaminated water sources due to numerous oil spills in the area. She and her community are forced to purchase clean water for essential needs, further straining their limited financial resources. Similar struggles are echoed by Paulina Agbekpekpe from Bodo, reminiscing about the lush environment that once thrived in her community before oil pollution took its toll.
“The 50-year-old mother of six spoke about the widespread pollution caused by spills, lamenting the devastation that has affected her family for generations. A decade ago, a catastrophic spill had shattered their traditional livelihood of fishing.
The impact was profound, with most of the children falling ill from contaminated drinking water, leading to diseases and tragic deaths. The woman shared the heart-wrenching loss of eight children and her husband’s deteriorating health. The community in Bodo faced hunger and hardship due to the loss of their means of survival.
In 2011, the UN’s Environment Programme (UNEP) released a significant study on the polluted oil-rich region. The report revealed alarming levels of a carcinogenic substance, benzene, in the water and air of the Ogoniland community, far exceeding WHO guidelines. Despite claims of remediation by Shell’s Nigerian subsidiary, the sites remained polluted, failing to meet regulatory standards.
The report estimated that a comprehensive cleanup effort would span 25-30 years, resulting in the establishment of the Hydrocarbon Pollution Remediation Project (Hyprep). Initially established in 2012 by the Nigerian government, the cleanup was delayed until a renewed effort in December 2016. Hyprep received funding from oil companies, including the state-owned Nigerian National Petroleum Company and Shell.
However, internal documents obtained by the BBC raised concerns about fraudulent practices within Hyprep. Allegations included the engagement of incompetent contractors and falsified laboratory results. Whistleblowers highlighted the misuse of funds, suggesting that the cleanup efforts were a guise to siphon money for personal gain.
Despite numerous warnings and reports of malpractice, both Shell and the Nigerian government have remained silent on the allegations. The British high commissioner to Nigeria acknowledged the challenges faced by Hyprep during a meeting with Shell representatives, hinting at the possibility of withholding future funding.
Shell emphasized that Hyprep operates under the Nigerian government’s oversight and governance, with limited representation from the affected communities and NGOs. The unfolding scandal underscores the urgent need for transparency and accountability in the cleanup efforts to restore the devastated region.”
In 2015, Shell reached a £55 million settlement for a cleanup effort following two devastating spills in 2008 that occurred in Bodo, a community within Ogoniland. The cleanup project, managed by the Bodo Mediation Initiative (BMI), aimed to serve as a bridge between oil companies like Shell and the Bodo community. This initiative, partially funded by Shell and Nigerian regulators, has been reported as 98% complete by the company.
A recent investigation by the BBC uncovered unsettling findings within the area. Despite Shell’s claims of near completion, evidence of crude oil seeping from the ground and contaminating water sources was observed. Shell and the BMI attribute these spills to theft, commonly referred to as “oil bunkering” in the industry.
Boniface Dumpe, a BMI director, assured that plans are in place to rectify the situation by bringing back contractors to clean the affected areas to specific standards. He emphasized the shared responsibility between stakeholders, including Shell and the community, to prevent further pollution incidents.
Shell stated that they are actively implementing measures to prevent oil spills resulting from illegal activities like oil bunkering. These measures include aerial surveillance, dismantling illegal pipeline connections, and installing protective structures around wellheads.
Amidst these challenges, Shell is in the process of finalizing the sale of its Nigerian subsidiary, SPDC, to Renaissance Africa, a consortium of local and international entities. Local residents in Ogoniland have expressed concerns over Shell’s perceived lack of commitment to thoroughly clean up the environment it allegedly contaminated. There are fears that Shell might continue to profit from the region through future oil trading activities.
The sale of the SPDC raises uncertainties regarding the future management of the pipelines and its potential impacts on the local community. Some residents feel that Shell is evading its responsibility to restore the land and water bodies affected by its operations. They worry about the implications of this change in ownership and the lack of transparency surrounding the deal.
The significance of oil in Nigeria’s economy cannot be overstated, with petroleum products constituting 90% of the country’s exports, primarily sourced from the Niger Delta region. Despite the economic benefits derived from the oil industry, local communities that heavily rely on agriculture and fishing have borne the brunt of environmental degradation and associated hardships.
Patience Ogboe, a 42-year-old resident, lamented the impact of recent oil spills on her crops, highlighting the struggle faced by many in the region. The exploitation of natural resources by oil companies, illegal oil activities, and corruption have exacerbated the plight of locals, who feel marginalized and deprived of the benefits promised by the “black gold” discovered in their homeland.
As the community grapples with the aftermath of environmental degradation and economic challenges, questions loom regarding accountability and the future of Ogoniland. The need for transparent governance, environmental restoration, and equitable distribution of resources remains paramount for the well-being of the region and its inhabitants.
For more updates on this developing story and other
