The fate of TikTok in the United States now rests with the Supreme Court, and the outlook for the app is not promising. The Court recently heard arguments regarding a law that may result in a ban on TikTok in the country. This law, signed by President Joe Biden in April, mandates that TikTok must be divested from its China-based parent company, ByteDance, or else face a ban in the US.
During the hearing, the Supreme Court appeared unsympathetic towards TikTok, with most justices leaning towards upholding the law. Tough questions were directed at TikTok’s legal team and its users regarding their argument that the law violates the First Amendment. The possibility of the ban going into effect on January 19 seems increasingly likely.
There are numerous uncertainties surrounding how the ban would be implemented, as there is no prior precedent for the US government blocking a major social media platform. The specifics of how the government plans to enforce the ban remain unclear. Even TikTok’s attorney expressed uncertainty about the logistics of a potential ban, indicating that the app would cease operating on January 19.
If the law takes effect, TikTok would be removed from app stores, preventing new downloads. Existing users could still access the app on their devices but would be unable to update it through the app stores, potentially leading to functionality issues over time. The government may also compel internet service providers to block access to TikTok, complicating the situation further.
While the fate of TikTok in the US hangs in the balance, it is unclear how existing users may be affected in the long run. The ban’s potential impact on cybersecurity and user experience remains a concern.
The path the government will take to block TikTok remains uncertain, but experts anticipate that there will likely be ways to circumvent it, such as through the use of a virtual private network (VPN). A VPN is a tool that can be easily downloaded and used to conceal a user’s location data, making it seem like they are browsing the internet from a different country.
According to Eva Galperin, social media apps and websites have been blocked in various countries in the past using a range of methods, each with differing levels of success. In Turkey, for instance, numerous social media platforms have been inaccessible for an extended period, prompting a widespread adoption of VPNs to bypass such restrictions.
Even if the ban on TikTok is implemented, it may not be permanent. ByteDance, the Chinese company behind TikTok, could opt to sell the platform to a non-Chinese entity to restore access for American users. There are interested buyers, including a group led by billionaire Frank McCourt and endorsed by renowned investor Kevin O’Leary, who have formally expressed their intent to acquire TikTok’s US operations. Despite ByteDance consistently asserting that the app is not for sale, the situation may evolve if the ban is enforced.
The stance of President-elect Donald Trump further complicates the potential ban on TikTok. Trump has voiced a commitment to safeguarding TikTok, leading to uncertainty surrounding the ban’s outcome. Prior to a recent Supreme Court hearing, Trump submitted a brief requesting a temporary halt to the ban’s initiation, which is scheduled to take effect one day before his inauguration. Trump aims to utilize his remaining time as president to negotiate a sale of TikTok.
Legal analysts have speculated that Trump could opt not to enforce the ban, signaling to major tech companies like Apple and Google that they would not face penalties for continuing to host TikTok on their platforms. However, the willingness of these companies to defy the law remains uncertain, even with potential assurances from Trump.
Francisco, representing TikTok’s legal team, highlighted the potential for significant changes following the transition to a new administration on January 20th. The uncertainty surrounding the situation has raised questions about the companies’ compliance with existing laws, regardless of any discretionary enforcement decisions by the incoming administration.
As the developments surrounding TikTok continue to unfold, the landscape remains dynamic. The interplay of legal, political, and commercial factors adds layers of complexity to the situation, leaving stakeholders and observers alike closely monitoring the evolving narrative.
For the latest news updates and newsletters from CNN, readers are encouraged to create an account at CNN.com.
