Ross Ulbricht, now 40 years old, was arrested at the age of 29 and currently faces a double life sentence plus 40 years with no chance of parole for his role in creating the Silk Road. This dark web marketplace facilitated $1.2 billion in bitcoin transactions related to illegal drugs.
In a 2021 interview from prison, Ulbricht expressed his grim outlook on the future, anticipating spending the next several decades behind bars and ultimately leaving prison in a body bag. However, a glimmer of hope emerged when former President Donald Trump pledged at the 2024 Libertarian National Convention to commute Ulbricht’s sentence if elected.
Following a deal struck with the Libertarian Party, there is a possibility that Ulbricht may not have to spend the rest of his life in prison if Trump fulfills his promise. Despite potential opposition from career FBI officials and Department of Justice attorneys who may attempt to discredit Ulbricht, Trump should honor his commitment to set him free.
Ulbricht’s arrest in 2013 at the San Francisco Public Library was a dramatic event, reminiscent of a movie scene, as he was caught managing the Silk Road while downloading an interview. Contrary to the ruthless drug kingpin persona, Ulbricht was an Eagle Scout and a scholar of libertarian philosophy and economics, aiming to create a world free of coercion and aggression through economic simulation.
Ulbricht’s creation of the Silk Road aimed to provide a platform for ethical drug transactions, with trusted sellers and a community ethos focused on harm reduction. His vision was to foster a more just and free society through this underground marketplace.
Despite the controversies surrounding his actions, Ulbricht believes he was striving for a noble cause, aiming to drive progress and foster a world based on fairness and freedom. The decision to commute his sentence would provide him with a second chance to contribute positively to society and redeem himself.
Payday lenders were operating legally on the Silk Road, showcasing how bitcoin enabled online purchases outside of government-controlled payment systems. This decentralized online trade was seen as unstoppable, with Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht reflecting on the limitless possibilities afforded by bitcoin. To some, Ulbricht became a libertarian hero, but his life sentence without parole was celebrated by others like Bill O’Reilly. Despite initial idealism, Ulbricht expressed remorse from jail, acknowledging his downfall from good intentions to a hellish reality. Questions arise about Ulbricht’s descent into paranoia and potential moral decline akin to Walter White, prompting debate on whether he should be pardoned. Described as sweet-natured and poetic by friends, Ulbricht’s character was also marred by allegations of contract killings during his Silk Road tenure. Prosecutors built a case using chat logs involving an undercover agent posing as a hitman targeting a thief on Silk Road, yet doubts persist about Ulbricht’s direct involvement. The enigmatic figure of the Dread Pirate Roberts, inspired by a character from a film, adds complexity to Ulbricht’s case, with claims that multiple individuals controlled the Silk Road account. An interview where the Dread Pirate Roberts denies being the site’s founder went unseen by the jury, further clouding Ulbricht’s involvement in Silk Road’s illicit activities.
The mother doesn’t believe Ulbricht was responsible for ordering the hit, stating that the undercover agent, Carl Force (aka Nob), also had access to the Dread Pirate Roberts’ account. Other hits orchestrated by the Dread Pirate Roberts did not result in known murders. While Ulbricht was not charged with attempted murder, the federal judge who sentenced him to two life sentences plus 40 years without parole referenced these incidents in her decision, condemning his attitude of superiority to the country’s laws. The real villain in Ulbricht’s story is the drug war, which has cost $1 trillion and fueled black market crime and violence, contributing to the rise in overdose deaths in the U.S.
It is ironic that Trump, who admires China and Singapore’s death penalty for drug dealers, may potentially release the founder of the Silk Road, the first major dark web drug market. Trump’s affinity for striking deals was evident in his agreement with the Libertarian Party during the 2024 campaign. Despite facing criticism at the Libertarian convention, behind the scenes, Trump had negotiated with party leaders to secure their support in exchange for freeing Ross Ulbricht.
After Trump’s narrow victory in swing states and the Libertarian Party’s lowest vote share in 16 years, the conditions were set for Trump to uphold his promise. The Silk Road was initially envisioned by Ulbricht as a safer platform for black market transactions, aiming to provide a space for vetting buyers, avoiding risky face-to-face deals, acquiring untainted drugs, and sharing safety tips. However, the platform ultimately succumbed to the same violent forces that plague all illicit markets throughout history, highlighting the challenges of addressing issues caused by prohibition.
Violence and the spread of dangerous synthetic drugs like fentanyl are identified as key drivers behind the ongoing overdose epidemic, a problem that has only exacerbated since the closure of Silk Road. The situation underscores the critical need for a reevaluation of current drug strategies by the government.
In the absence of a significant shift in drug policies, individuals seeking illicit substances are left with limited options, primarily resorting to platforms akin to Silk Road and its numerous imitators, or turning to organized crime syndicates such as the cartels. While President Trump has pledged to dismantle these criminal organizations, drawing a parallel to the successful dismantling of the ISIS caliphate, past attempts to eradicate cartels have proven to be challenging and often counterproductive.
Previous efforts to target cartel leadership in the early 2010s resulted in a surge of violence in Mexico, ultimately leading to the emergence of figures like “El Chapo.” The subsequent power vacuum left by his arrest allowed for a more decentralized and adaptable cartel structure to emerge. Under new leadership, the flow of fentanyl into the United States escalated, with seizures nearly doubling between 2021 and 2023.
As long as there remains a substantial demand for drugs within the American market, there will persistently be willing suppliers. The failure of drug prohibition has been evident, rendering aggressive tactics like targeting drug dealers or engaging in military operations in Mexico ineffective in addressing the root causes of the issue.
Even for those who believe in Trump’s ability to achieve success in the war on drugs, the continued imprisonment of individuals like Ross Ulbricht, the founder of Silk Road, raises ethical questions. Ulbricht, a first-time offender, has expressed remorse for his role in facilitating drug abuse and addiction. Despite being eligible for release had he accepted a previous plea deal, Ulbricht has demonstrated exemplary behavior while incarcerated, pursuing education and engaging in positive activities within the prison community.
Advocates for Ulbricht’s release argue that his continued imprisonment is unjust, particularly in comparison to controversial pardons granted by President Biden to individuals like his son Hunter. The support for Ulbricht’s freedom stems from a belief in honoring agreements made, such as the deal brokered by Trump that resonated with many of Ulbricht’s supporters.
In navigating the complex landscape of 21st-century American politics, the call for Ulbricht’s release represents a potential opportunity for a more compassionate and equitable approach. As debates surrounding criminal justice reform and drug policy continue to evolve, the case of Ross Ulbricht serves as a focal point for discussions on fairness, rehabilitation, and the broader implications of punitive measures in combating drug-related issues.
Producer: John Osterhoudt
Graphics: Lex Villena
The post Trump Promised To Free Ross Ulbricht. Here’s Why He Should. appeared first on Reason.com.
