Democratic Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania experienced a tense meeting with representatives from a teachers union in his home state recently. Witnesses described Fetterman becoming agitated, repeating himself, and questioning why people were upset with him. He slammed his hands on a desk and made some unsettling remarks, causing a staff member to end the meeting and escort the visitors out, where one person broke down in tears. The incident occurred in Fetterman’s Washington office the day before New York Magazine published a story raising concerns about the senator’s mental health.
The magazine story included a letter from Fetterman’s former chief of staff expressing worries about Fetterman deviating from his recovery plan and displaying concerning behavior. Fetterman responded, stating that the meeting with the teachers union was a discussion about frustrations with education cuts and his support for public schools. He dismissed the magazine story as a “hit piece” and denied any validity to the concerns about his well-being.
Despite surviving a stroke and battling depression in recent years, questions about Fetterman’s mental health have resurfaced. Criticism has emerged over his willingness to cooperate with former President Donald Trump, causing alarm among some Democrats in Pennsylvania. Fetterman, who has been open about his struggles and recovery, has emphasized the importance of seeking help for mental health issues.
In a recent conversation, Fetterman mentioned, “I played in that game and am currently here speaking with you.” However, some close associates question whether Fetterman has fully recovered. In a letter to Dr. David Williamson in 2024, Jentleson expressed concerns that Fetterman was neglecting medical appointments, dismissing those meant to support his recovery plan, and possibly not following his prescribed medication regimen. Jentleson also noted instances of reckless driving, paranoia, and isolation from colleagues. Jentleson stated that Fetterman had dismantled the agreed-upon early-warning system established upon his release, engaging in conflicts with each person involved and alienating them from his health status information.
Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, where Williamson practices, declined an interview request citing patient privacy laws.
Known for his independent streak, Fetterman has made a name for himself in politics, operating outside traditional party lines. Rising to prominence as a mayor in Braddock, Fetterman gained attention for his progressive approach, distinctive appearance, and unconventional efforts to revitalize the town. He broke ranks to endorse Bernie Sanders in the 2016 primary and ran against the party-backed candidate in the Senate primary that same year. During his tenure as lieutenant governor in 2020, Fetterman emerged as a key advocate for Joe Biden’s presidential campaign, garnering a national following and excelling in grassroots fundraising.
Elected to the Senate in 2022, Fetterman’s unorthodox attire, casual demeanor, and outspoken nature have set him apart. Following his hospitalization in 2023, he returned as a more engaging figure, interacting jovially with colleagues and utilizing technology to facilitate communication. Despite his affable nature, Fetterman maintains a degree of separation from fellow Democrats, particularly on matters related to Israel and Trump. He has advocated for cooperation with the former president, even meeting with him and supporting some of his nominees, a stance that has drawn criticism from within his party.
While Fetterman remains a polarizing figure, his evolving positions have earned both support and backlash. Despite disagreements with progressives over Israel policy, Fetterman remained active in campaigning for Democratic candidates in Pennsylvania. However, his nuanced approach to Trump and internal party dynamics has led to a shift in public perception. Former supporters have expressed disappointment, prompting Fetterman to navigate a complex political landscape marked by divergent opinions and shifting alliances.
During an episode of the political talk show “Real Time with Bill Maher,” the host suggested that Fetterman should consider running for president in 2028. Despite being a target of criticism by conservatives due to his progressive politics, Fetterman has received support from unexpected corners. However, Democrats in Pennsylvania have expressed concerns about Fetterman’s well-being. Sharif Street, the state’s Democratic Party chairman, noted that people are worried about Fetterman’s health and are eager to ensure his well-being, reflecting the widespread affection for him. This report includes contributions from Associated Press reporter Mary Clare Jalonick in Washington. For more updates from Marc Levy, visit https://x.com/timelywriter.
