A significant shift is occurring in South Africa’s relationship with the US following President Donald Trump’s controversial decision to cut financial aid to the country. Trump accused South Africa of engaging in what he deemed as “unjust and immoral practices” against the white minority Afrikaner community. This move has caused upheaval in South Africa, with concerns rising that Trump may consider ending preferential access to the US market through the Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa).
Since the end of white-minority rule in 1994, South Africa and the US have maintained friendly relations. However, tensions escalated after Trump’s inauguration when South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa signed the Expropriation Bill into law, allowing the government to confiscate land without compensation in certain circumstances. Trump responded by threatening to cut future funding due to what he perceived as unfavorable actions by the South African leadership.
In response, Trump issued an executive order freezing aid amounting to nearly $440 million, although funding from Pepfar, a program combating HIV spread, will not be affected entirely. Trump also accused South Africa of disregarding its citizens’ rights and taking aggressive stances against the US and Israel in the International Court of Justice. He further offered assistance to refugees from the Afrikaner community to settle in the US.
Conservative Afrikaner lobby groups, supported by individuals like Elon Musk, have criticized South Africa’s policies, including affirmative action and black economic empowerment laws. Trump’s criticisms echo his previous remarks on South Africa’s land reform policies, drawing attention to issues such as the treatment of farmers and land seizure.
While President Trump’s comments initially triggered criticism, Dr. Oscar van Heerden, a political analyst at the University of Johannesburg, highlighted to the BBC that such extreme actions, culminating in an executive order, had never been witnessed before. Currently, the relationship between the two nations is at a delicate juncture, with both sides contemplating their next steps.
Regarding trade, Donald MacKay, the CEO of XA Global Trade Advisors, a trade consultancy based in Johannesburg, noted that although the US is a significant trading partner for South Africa, it is not its closest ally. South Africa exports various minerals to the US, including platinum, iron, and manganese. Additionally, as one of the major beneficiaries under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), South Africa earns approximately $2.7 billion in revenue, primarily from the sale of vehicles, jewelry, and metals.
While the historical trade relationship has experienced fluctuations since the end of white-minority rule in South Africa, recent years have seen a notable deterioration, as acknowledged by Mr. MacKay in his conversation with the BBC. He attributed these tensions partly to South Africa’s actions that have irked the US over time. The changing global landscape, with emerging competition from countries like China, India, and Brazil challenging the US, has also played a role in reshaping the dynamics.
Experts have emphasized the advantages of AGOA, set for review later this year, but suggest that the impact might not be as severe as feared. With doubts about South Africa’s continued eligibility under AGOA post-review, Mr. MacKay speculated that it could be utilized by President Trump to penalize South Africa for the current tensions.
Dr. van Heerden acknowledged that the potential exclusion from AGOA might cause short-term losses for South African businesses, but they could recover over time. Despite pursuing diplomatic channels, the South African government faces challenges due to the Trump administration’s apparent disinterest in diplomacy, exacerbating the difficulty in resolving the situation.
South Africa’s firm stance on issues, exemplified by Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola’s response to Trump’s actions, underscores its commitment to its principles, even if it leads to consequences. The ongoing dispute with Israel at the International Court of Justice further complicates the situation.
In parallel efforts to maintain international relationships, President Ramaphosa’s delegation will embark on a global tour to clarify South Africa’s policies, with Washington being a key destination. Assuming the G20 presidency in December last year, South Africa aims to enhance its global influence through this platform, although recent events have strained its ties with the US.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has made headlines by announcing his decision to skip an upcoming G20 meeting of foreign ministers in Johannesburg. In a bold statement, Rubio emphasized his commitment to furthering America’s national interests, citing a reluctance to squander taxpayer funds or entertain anti-American sentiments.
The meeting in question holds particular significance as South Africa, a member of the Brics alliance alongside Brazil, Russia, India, and China, plays host. Brics, a coalition of major developing nations, aims to challenge the dominance of North American and Western European powers on the global stage.
Observers are closely watching how South Africa and other nations will navigate their relationships with the United States, given what has been described as the unpredictability of the current American leadership. Some speculate that these countries may increasingly look towards Brics as a viable alternative partner in light of recent political shifts.
In a reassuring move for South Africa, the European Union, a key trading partner, has reiterated its commitment to strengthening ties with the country. European Council President António Costa recently reached out to South African President Ramaphosa, underscoring the EU’s dedication to fostering a closer relationship.
As South Africa seeks to cultivate stronger ties with various global players, there is a sense of urgency in ensuring successful negotiations. Should traditional charm initiatives fall short, some experts suggest that the country may need to take a more assertive stance, potentially using its mineral resources as leverage in discussions with the US.
However, caution is advised as South Africa navigates this complex geopolitical landscape. With President Trump and entrepreneur Elon Musk already making moves on the metaphorical chessboard of international relations, strategic decision-making becomes paramount for South Africa’s leadership.
For more updates on African affairs, visit BBCAfrica.com. Stay connected with us on social media for the latest news and insights. Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, Facebook at BBC Africa, and Instagram at bbcafrica to stay informed and engaged with the continent’s developments.
