Buffalo, N.Y. – Peter Gerace, the owner of Pharaoh’s Gentlemen’s Club who is facing charges related to sex and drug trafficking, used to live in a lavish 3,600-square-foot house in Clarence complete with marble counters, a gym, full basement and bar, signed sports memorabilia on the walls, and a salt-water pool with a hot tub. However, his financial situation has taken a drastic turn, with Gerace now claiming he cannot afford to pay his attorneys.
In 2023, Gerace sold his house for $1.15 million and also sold a substantial collection of sports and movie memorabilia that adorned his basement walls. Additionally, his club’s profitability has declined. As a result, U.S. District Judge Lawrence Vilardo has allowed Gerace to retain his legal team, with their fees to be covered by taxpayers due to his financial difficulties.
During the trial, a juror fell ill, leading to their replacement by a substitute. The jury had to discard their notes and start deliberations anew. The trial, which has seen multiple delays and interruptions, has now extended beyond two months.
Despite various setbacks, the trial has proceeded, with arguments over the admissibility of certain evidence and witness testimonies. One of Gerace’s ex-wives had sent an email criticizing a key witness, but the judge ruled to exclude it from the evidence. The prosecution also faced limitations on questioning two inmates who had agreements with the government in exchange for their cooperation.
Witnesses, including a former bouncer and manager of Pharaoh’s, expressed frustration at the trial delays. The proceedings have been marked by tensions between witnesses, attorneys, and the court.
Complaints were made about Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicholas Cooper’s style of questioning during the legal proceedings. Vilardo advised the individual in question to respond to Cooper’s inquiries and, in situations where an answer was not readily available, to simply state, “I don’t recall.”
