Many California homeowners are facing a challenging situation as insurers have canceled millions of policies in the state since 2020. According to Los Angeles insurance agent Carla Ramirez, major carriers have stopped renewing or issuing new homeowner policies due to what they perceive as high-risk areas. In light of reassessments of fire risks, previously deemed safe neighborhoods like Palisades and Malibu are now considered high-risk, prompting insurers to take action to mitigate potential losses.
Shya Mousavipour shared the story of his parents, who lost their Malibu home in a fire after being dropped by their insurance company. Forced to switch to the California FAIR plan, they found themselves underinsured compared to their previous coverage. The FAIR plan, designed as a last-resort option, often comes with higher premiums and less comprehensive coverage than private insurers, leaving policyholders to cobble together additional coverage to match their previous benefits at a higher cost.
The impact of the insurance crisis is felt throughout the state, with homeowners like Jamie Lite and Celeste Vander Ham struggling to secure adequate coverage. Lite, whose premiums skyrocketed before being dropped by her insurer, now faces uncertainty and rising costs with a new carrier. She feels trapped, unable to sell her home due to insurance challenges, while Vander Ham and her husband pay a hefty sum to insure their property after being deemed high-risk post-wildfire.
The financial burden on homeowners is significant, with many feeling the strain on their limited incomes. As insurers reassess risks and discontinue policies, residents are left grappling with the aftermath of disasters and the complexities of navigating the insurance market in a state prone to natural disasters.
Security benefits, and she is his caretaker. With just eight years remaining on their mortgage, they had to refinance their home, taking on another 30-year loan to afford insurance. She now anticipates they will have to sell their house and relocate to a different state. “It’s truly heart-wrenching,” she lamented. “We’re being pushed out due to homeowner’s insurance.”
Ramirez, the insurance agent, justified the state’s fire risks as the reason for the higher premiums and suggested that homeowners are not fully considering “the true costs” of residing in these areas. “If your area was historically low-risk for fires but is now becoming high-risk, that is the price of living there,” she remarked. “If living there exceeds your means, then perhaps relocating is the answer.”
In California, homeowners traditionally had the choice between admitted and non-admitted carriers. Admitted carriers, such as State Farm, Allstate, and Farmers, are state-licensed and must adhere to pricing regulations, which they argued made it challenging to insure high-risk regions. Non-admitted carriers are usually smaller insurers that operate without the same regulations, allowing them to charge higher premiums but offer coverage in riskier locales.
Admitted carriers have been withdrawing from California for the past two years. Allstate ceased issuing new policies in the state in 2022, Farmers imposed a limit on California policies in July 2023, and State Farm halted new policy issuance in May 2023, with an announcement in 2024 that around 72,000 policies would not be renewed. Farmers and State Farm did not respond immediately to a comment request.
Allstate stated that they “paused the sale of homeowners insurance policies for new customers in 2022. We continue to provide coverage to most existing homeowners insurance customers… In relation to wildfires, we have deployed claim personnel and multiple mobile claim centers in California to support our customers individually and assist them in filing claims,” as well as contributing to disaster relief efforts.
Homeowners who were dropped by these carriers were surprised by the prices of the FAIR plan or non-admitted carriers, which could range from $20,000 to $30,000 annually in fire-prone areas, Ramirez noted. “Many opted to maintain lower coverage due to the shock of the cost,” she explained. “Your premium tripled, and we’re advising you to double it further, leading people to think, ‘Hmm, maybe not.’ This has left many Californians either uninsured or underinsured as they cope with the aftermath of the devastation.”
Comey and Mousavipour, along with other residents, acknowledged that insurance companies operate for profit, but they find the current system unsustainable. “We need a solution where residents in these areas are fully insured, and since these are private companies, they must be incentivized to want to operate here,” Mousavipour stated. “The solution isn’t to prevent people from living there, but
Former FBI Director James Comey criticized insurance companies for prioritizing corporate profits over people’s lives in the aftermath of a devastating fire that resulted in loss of life and property. Comey highlighted the need to reevaluate societal values that place financial gain above human well-being. He underscored the struggles faced by individuals who lacked insurance coverage or had their policies terminated, leading to financial hardships.
In response to the crisis, community members rallied on GoFundMe to support affected homeowners, many of whom were left without adequate insurance protection. A fundraiser for Comey’s family garnered significant contributions, reflecting the solidarity and compassion displayed by donors. Despite expressing gratitude for the outpouring of support, Comey lamented the systemic failures that force individuals to rely on crowdfunding platforms for essential financial assistance.
The situation exposed broader issues within the capitalist system, shedding light on the inadequacies of existing safety nets and the challenges faced by those grappling with unexpected crises. Comey’s remarks underscored the urgent need for a reevaluation of societal priorities to ensure that individuals are not left vulnerable in times of need.
For the latest news and updates from CNN, readers are encouraged to sign up for an account on CNN.com for access to exclusive content and newsletters.
