Title: The Ultimate Frozen Pizza Showdown Unveiled
We all have a soft spot for pizza, whether fresh or frozen. The frozen section of grocery stores is packed with various brands and styles of frozen pizzas, making it challenging to determine which one offers the best value. To uncover the champion of frozen pizzas, we embarked on a taste-testing journey, trying out a wide range of options available in the market.
Here are some of the pizzas we sampled:
– DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Pepperoni
– DiGiorno Thin & Crispy Tomato Mozzarella with Pesto
– Signature Select Rising Crust Five Cheese Pizza
– Signature Select Ultra Thin Crust Margherita Pizza
– Trader Joe’s Pizza 4 Formaggi
– Freschetta Canadian Style Bacon & Pineapple
– Freschetta Four Cheese
– Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni
– Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni
– Tombstone Original Pepperoni
– Totino’s Pizza Party
– Amy’s Cheese Pizza
– California Pizza Kitchen Crispy Thin Crust BBQ Chicken Pizza
Approaching this tasting with unbiased opinions, we assessed each pizza based on its taste and quality. Among the notable findings were:
– Best Frozen Pepperoni: Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni
– Best Actual Cheese: Signature Select Five Cheese
– Best Crust: DiGiorno Original Rising Crust
– Best Sauce: Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni
– Best Non-Tomato Sauce: CPK BBQ Chicken
Each pizza had its unique attributes, but the winners stood out for their exceptional taste and quality. Whether you prefer a classic pepperoni, a cheesy delight, or a unique sauce, there is a frozen pizza out there to satisfy your cravings.
Best Enjoyed with a side of sauce, the California Pizza Kitchen pie offers a well-cooked onion and chicken that doesn’t taste frozen. The crust has its pros and cons – it’s light and crispy, making it easy to devour without feeling heavy, but hardens quickly like eating off a matzoh piece.
DiGiorno’s Thin & Crispy Tomato Mozzarella with Pesto is a fresh and flavorful choice, reminiscent of pizzetti from an Italian restaurant. The fresh tomatoes and unfrozen pesto add to its appeal. Though the thin crust differs from a rising crust, it’s clear this is intentional. This pizza is satisfying without leaving you uncomfortably full.
Freschetta, a good choice for reheating the next day, offers a doughy crust that doesn’t taste frozen post-microwave. While the toppings might vary, the dough stands out for retaining its quality.
For a post-party 3 a.m. treat, Totino’s Party Pizza is a convenient and nostalgic option with its square shape and toaster oven preparation. It’s straightforward junk food that delivers on taste and ease.
When it comes to a pleasant unboxing experience, Signature Select from Vons stands out for being easy to handle, with toppings frozen in place. In contrast, Screamin’ Sicilian can be messy upon opening, and Totino’s lacks a box, presenting broken bits in a small sleeve.
Amy’s vegan and gluten-free pizza is a commendable choice, with cheese-like texture, flavorful sauce, and a crust made of rice. It’s a satisfying option for those seeking plant-based alternatives.
Regrettably, Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni is deemed the worst frozen pizza, suitable for emergencies only. Trader Joe’s Pizza 4 Formaggi disappoints with burn marks before even entering the oven, potentially misleading consumers about its wood-fired origins.
While the pizza boasts “imported ingredients,” the blend of cheeses – including edam, asiago, pecorino, and Grana Padano – leaves much to be desired. It’s a surprising letdown from a company known for its freezer section prowess. However, we’re not angry, just somewhat underwhelmed. Instacart’s pick for the best frozen pizza overall is the Signature Select Five Cheese, available for $5 at Vons. A must-try choice that caught us off guard. Even after being blown away by the Screamin’ Sicilian, the following day’s encounter with the Signature Select Five Cheese proved to be a pleasant surprise. This frozen pizza genuinely mimics the taste and texture of a traditional pizza, with a delightful interplay between the cheese and sauce that delivers an authentic pizza experience. Kudos to the folks at Signature Select for this remarkable creation. Read more about this review on Cheapism’s website.
