Comparing Aldi and Name Brand Products in Taste Test
As food prices rise, more shoppers are turning to stores like Aldi for affordable groceries. Aldi, a discount chain with expanding stores nationwide, has been attracting more foot traffic. One noticeable aspect for newcomers to Aldi is the striking similarity of some of its products to well-known name brands. While store brands often mimic their name-brand counterparts to some extent, Aldi seems to have perfected this practice. But beyond the look-alike packaging, how do Aldi’s products stack up in taste against the brands we are familiar with? To find out, I conducted a taste test to potentially help you save money in your grocery shopping endeavor.
Methodology:
In a blind taste test, I evaluated how closely each Aldi product matched a similar name brand product from Kroger on taste using a four-point scale:
– Nice try
– Somewhat similar
– Very similar
– Dead ringer
After rating the products for taste, I factored in the price difference to determine whether I would choose to purchase the Aldi product again.
Apple Juice Comparison:
Aldi’s Nature’s Nectar Apple Juice closely resembles Mott’s Apple Juice, both in taste and appearance, yet comes at a significantly lower price point. While Mott’s was priced at $4.99 for a similar-sized bottle at Kroger, Aldi’s version was only $2.35. The verdict? A dead ringer in taste and quality, making it a compelling choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Sliced Turkey Comparison:
For those packing turkey sandwiches, Aldi’s Lunch Mate Turkey breast offers a cost-effective alternative to Oscar Meyer’s Deli Fresh Oven Roasted Turkey. Priced at $2.59 for a 9-ounce packet, Aldi’s turkey was indistinguishable in taste from the name brand despite the lower price point. A great option for those looking to save without compromising on flavor.
American Cheese Comparison:
Aldi’s Happy Farms Singles offer a wallet-friendly option compared to Kraft’s American Singles. While Kraft’s slices cost $3.79, Aldi’s version comes in at $1.65 for 16 slices. The taste and texture of Aldi’s cheese slices were on par with the name brand, making it a worthy substitute for grilled cheese sandwiches or snacks.
Blueberry Mini Muffins Comparison:
Aldi’s Baker’s Treat brand of Blueberry Mini Muffins provides a more affordable option compared to similar name brand products. With a price of $2.55, these mini muffins can become a more frequent treat without breaking the bank.
In conclusion, Aldi’s products not only offer substantial savings but also deliver comparable quality and taste to their name brand counterparts, making them a smart choice for budget-conscious consumers.
Aldi’s Blueberry Mini Muffins cost 51 cents per pouch, while Hostess at Kroger is priced at $3.99, making it 80 cents per pouch. The Aldi muffins closely resembled the name brand in appearance, smell, and taste, prompting me to confirm I was indeed tasting both brands. I would definitely repurchase these mini muffins, much to the delight of my children.
When it comes to ketchup, Aldi’s Burman’s brand priced at $1.35 for a 38-ounce bottle is a steal at about 4 cents per ounce, compared to Heinz at Kroger for $3.13, which is approximately 8 cents per ounce. The taste, color, and consistency of Aldi’s ketchup were very similar to Heinz, raising the question of why people opt for the pricier name brand. I would definitely buy Aldi’s ketchup again.
A 12-count box of Millville Toaster Tarts at Aldi for $1.65 closely resembles Kellogg’s Pop-Tarts, which cost $2.99 at Kroger. The Aldi toaster pastries are priced at just under 14 cents each, compared to 25 cents for the name brand. Despite being slightly sweeter, I found myself preferring Aldi’s version and would purchase them again for the cost savings.
Aldi’s Breakfast Best Homestyle Waffles at $1.35 for 10 waffles offer a great alternative to Eggo waffles priced at $2.49 for a 10-count package at Kroger. The taste of Aldi’s waffles was nearly identical to Eggo, but with a lighter, crispier texture that I preferred. I would choose Aldi’s waffles again, considering both the taste and price point.
Millville Fruit Rounds at Aldi for $1.45 per 12-ounce box are a cost-effective option compared to Kellogg’s Froot Loops at $3.54 for a 10.1-ounce box at Kroger. While the appearance of Aldi’s cereal differs slightly, the taste is very similar, with Kellogg’s Froot Loops being slightly sweeter. I would purchase Aldi’s Fruity Cereal again, especially since my kids enjoy it.
Aldi’s Baker’s Treat Swiss Rolls are priced at just $1.49 for 12 cakes or 12 cents each, offering a more budget-friendly option compared to the popular Little Debbie brand.
At Kroger, we purchased a 12-pack of Little Debbie Swiss Rolls for $1.99, averaging around 17 cents per cake. Aldi’s Swiss Rolls are very similar in taste to Little Debbie’s, although not as visually appealing or easy to handle. While they may be a little sweeter, the chocolate coating tends to flake off more easily. Despite these differences, I would buy them again to save money, even though my waistline may not be as happy.
When it comes to corn chips, the siren call of the yellow bag is hard to resist, but Aldi offers a more budget-friendly option. Clancy’s Corn Chips Big Dippers cost 85 cents for a 9.25-ounce bag at Aldi, compared to $4.49 for a 15.5-ounce bag of Fritos Scoops at Kroger. The flavor of Clancy’s chips closely resembles that of Fritos, making them a great choice for party snacks.
Aldi’s Clancy’s Cheese Curls may resemble Cheetos in appearance, but they come at a lower price. Priced at $1.65 for an 8.5-ounce bag, they offer a cheesy snack alternative that won’t break the bank. While they are slightly less cheesy and more bready than Cheetos, they are still a good option, especially for parties.
For cheese pizza rolls, Aldi offers Mama Cozzi’s Cheese Pizza Snacks at a lower cost compared to Totino’s Pizza Rolls at Kroger. The flavor profile of Aldi’s pizza rolls is cheesier with a puffier crust, while Totino’s has a more prominent sauce taste and chewier texture. Both brands offer a similar experience, so the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference.
In the realm of vegetarian options, Aldi’s Earth Grown Chickenless Patties provide a healthier alternative to traditional chicken patties. Priced at $3.65 for four patties, they are slightly cheaper than MorningStar Farms Original Chick Veggie Patties at Kroger. However, the taste and texture of Aldi’s Chickenless Patties fell short compared to MorningStar’s offering, with a chewier and less appealing profile.
Even if you offered me money, Aldi’s Diet Summit Cola cannot be mistaken for anything other than an attempt to imitate Diet Coke. The difference in price is staggering: a dozen cans of Aldi’s soda cost $2.65, while a 12-pack of Diet Coke at Kroger is priced at $5.49. This means Aldi’s soda is only 22 cents per can, compared to the hefty 46 cents per can for the name brand.
Upon trying Aldi’s Diet Cola, I immediately noticed a distinct cola scent that Diet Coke lacks. This difference in aroma translated to the taste as well, with Aldi’s soda offering a more robust flavor compared to the smooth and mild Diet Coke. Additionally, Aldi’s brand had less carbonation.
As a dedicated Diet Coke enthusiast, I personally would not purchase Aldi’s version again. However, if you prefer the taste of regular Coke and are not put off by its sweetness, you might enjoy the bolder flavor of Diet Summit.
For more valuable shopping guides and grocery tips, be sure to subscribe to our free newsletters.
