Louis Duncan-He, the creative mind behind Louis Duncan-He Designs, believes that kitchen surfaces are a wonderful canvas to experiment with color and texture. Whether you prefer the elegance of swirling marble, the softness of creamy quartzite, or the boldness of a surprising black stone slab, the options are endless. However, with such a vast array of choices, narrowing down to just one surface can be a daunting task. This leads to the question: Can your kitchen island have a different surface than the rest of your counters?
We reached out to three design experts for their insights on mixing and matching countertops and selecting the perfect option to ensure your kitchen island always exudes sophistication. Let’s meet the experts:
– Esther Ellard, an interior designer and the visionary behind Effortless Designs.
– Louis Duncan-He, the president and creative director of Louis Duncan-He Designs.
– Catherine B. de la Sablonnière, the creative director of Ateliers Jacob Group.
The consensus among designers is that having a distinct kitchen island surface from the rest of your counters is not only acceptable but can be a deliberate design choice that enhances the visual appeal of your kitchen. According to Esther Ellard, a contrasting island surface can add a captivating visual element and act as a focal point that uplifts the kitchen style. It also allows for the exploration of texture and personality while defining the island as a versatile area for various activities.
Louis Duncan-He suggests that opting for a different countertop for your kitchen island is a strategic way to incorporate natural stone into your kitchen decor without overspending. When executed thoughtfully, mixing and matching surfaces can result in a more effortlessly stylish look. Catherine B. de la Sablonnière emphasizes that the key is the intention and significance behind the selection, viewing each material, finish, and color as essential components of a harmonious composition.
If you are considering a unique kitchen island, there are numerous island-counter combinations recommended by designers. For those seeking to make a statement or anchor their space, a sculptural or expressive island can set the tone, as suggested by Louis Duncan-He. Meanwhile, de la Sablonnière prefers surfaces with character, varied thickness, or striking silhouettes to create a captivating presence.
Functionality should also guide your choice, especially if the island serves as a gathering spot or a cooking area. Materials like Dekton are favored by de la Sablonnière for their durability and aesthetic appeal. Ellard leans towards pairings such as darker, single-tone quartz for their timeless elegance.
For more design inspiration and decor ideas, sign up for our free daily newsletter!
“In the kitchen, a lighter, swirly, patterned stone is used for the island while a different tone is chosen for the surrounding countertops. Ursula Carmona of Home Made by Carmona explains that the island’s tone creates a subtle drama, while the countertops add elegance and warmth, striking a sophisticated balance. However, Ellard advises prioritizing practical surfaces over purely aesthetic choices. It is important to choose materials that not only complement each other visually but also offer equal durability and quality, especially in high-traffic areas like a kitchen. Mixing materials like marble and quartz may not be ideal for active family households, as all surfaces will experience wear and tear. It is essential to ensure that the chosen materials can withstand the demands of your lifestyle.” – Excerpt from the original article on The Spruce
