Jeanette Bartlett has only fleeting memories of her older sister, 17-year-old Patty Bartlett, who had a passion for photography. Patty discovered her love for taking pictures during a photo science class at Pennsbury High School in Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania. Despite receiving a scholarship to pursue her photography studies further, Patty tragically never had the chance to do so.
Patty was described as a beautiful and talented young woman by her siblings. In January 1975, Patty was brutally murdered in the parking lot of the Oxford Valley Mall. The incident occurred as she was returning from a camera shop, preparing to take pictures in the impending snow. Despite her efforts to seek help, Patty succumbed to her injuries after fighting for her life for 50 minutes.
The heinous crime left the family devastated, and the lack of witnesses and evidence presented significant challenges to the investigation. Patty’s siblings, Jeff and Jeanette, continue to seek justice for their beloved sister, whose life was tragically cut short.
“Jeff recalled the moment when his dad said, ‘What’s wrong, Dad?’ and then asked him to come home. Upon arriving home, he was shocked to find all the cops in the driveway, making it the worst day of his life. The events at his girlfriend’s house unfolded, revealing that Patty had his girlfriend’s license. Jeanette speculated that Patty might have had the ID due to the legal drinking age being 18 in the past.
Jeanette’s memories of Patty’s murder are vague, recalling only the lights and sirens of that evening. She had a premonition of something wrong, even before anyone realized it. Jeff vividly remembers the overwhelming turnout at Patty’s funeral, with thousands paying their respects.
The family struggled with the trauma of Patty’s murder, each coping differently based on their ages. Jeanette had a tough time in school and experienced nightmares and trauma afterward. The support of their parents was crucial during this difficult period.
As the Bartlett family tried to move forward, the Middletown Township Police Department and Bucks County District Attorney’s Office worked to solve the case. Authorities ruled out robbery as the motive, as Patty’s wallet and purse were left untouched.
Despite thorough investigations, the case remained unsolved. Jeff expressed regret for not being able to protect Patty, especially considering the unsettling incidents leading up to her death.
The authorities looked into a stalker incident and an unidentified male seen with Patty shortly before her murder, but the leads did not yield any conclusive results. DA Schorn commended the efforts of the investigating officers, acknowledging the challenges faced due to the limitations of the ’70s.”
Experts and theories regarding the crime have been scrutinized over the past five decades. A spokesperson declined to delve into specific details or reveal information about the collected evidence, but stressed the unwavering commitment of detectives to thoroughly examine the available evidence. “The highly skilled detectives, knowledgeable about the resources in the realm of forensic science, have meticulously analyzed and will continue to analyze the evidence, particularly in light of advancements in DNA technology,” she stated. “Regrettably, in many instances, forensic evidence does not emerge as the decisive factor leading to resolving a case.”
Time can be both a foe and an ally in the realm of detectives, as the District Attorney notes, “In specific scenarios, time may work in our favor.” She remains optimistic that time will prove advantageous in Patty’s case. The pivotal strategy, in her view, is to maintain public awareness of cases like Patty’s. “Sometimes, public visibility prompts individuals to come forward and acknowledge, ‘Now is the time to speak up,'” she emphasized. “It is likely that someone possesses crucial information; thus, it is imperative for them to come forward.”
Schorn expresses hope that the individual withholding information will gather the courage to step forward, thereby offering a semblance of closure to Patty’s family. “No detail is insignificant, and if you believe you have pertinent information, do not dismiss its relevance,” she asserted. “Allow the detectives to sift through the details.”
Given the prolonged duration of the case, Jeanette Bartlett acknowledges the possibility that her sister’s killer may never be brought to justice. “Many of these individuals may have already passed away, but I remain undeterred,” she declared. “I seek answers regarding the who and the why.”
Jeff Bartlett echoes his sister’s sentiments but finds solace in one belief, “Divine justice will prevail against the perpetrator of this heinous act.” Individuals possessing information concerning Patty Bartlett’s murder are urged to contact Bucks County Detectives at 215-348-6354 or the Middletown Township Police Department at 215-750-3870.
Tips can be conveyed through CrimeWatch at www.bucksda.org or submitted to the Middletown Township Police Department at www.mtpd.org via the anonymous tips link or the anonymous tip phone line at 215-750-3888. If you have a compelling story to share with Dateline, please submit it through the provided link.
