Title: Doge Leader Revealed in a Twist of Mystery
A federal judge raised a straightforward query to the Trump administration’s legal team on Monday afternoon: Is Elon Musk, the tech billionaire, serving as the head of the Department of Government Efficiency, also known as “Doge”? Although Musk is the mastermind behind the agency, the White House denies his leadership role or employment within it.
During the court session, Justice Department lawyer Bradley Humphreys shared that he had limited information, stating, “I don’t have any information beyond he’s a close adviser to the president.” White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt reiterated this stance at a press briefing on Tuesday, asserting that President Trump had assigned Musk to oversee the Doge initiative. However, she clarified that Musk was supported by career officials and appointees in managing Doge, with newly appointed federal employees working across various agencies.
Leavitt refrained from divulging specific names but revealed that Musk was slated to join President Trump’s initial cabinet secretaries meeting alongside high-ranking political appointees, such as the Secretary of Defense and the Attorney General, who had received Senate confirmation.
Max Stier, president and CEO of the nonpartisan Partnership for Public Service, criticized the ambiguity surrounding Musk’s role, emphasizing the need for Senate confirmation and adherence to conflict of interest laws if he were truly the administrator of Doge.
Observers noted Musk’s predominant influence over Doge through his staffing decisions and vocal support, such as his appearances with the President and active engagement at public events. Despite Trump’s executive order renaming the United States Digital Service as the United States Doge Service and outlining its leadership structure, the document does not assign a specific individual to the role of USDS Administrator, although Musk’s contributions have been acknowledged by the President.
The establishment of Doge led to unrest within the existing US Digital Service workforce, resulting in dismissals and resignations amid security concerns raised by departing employees. Legal challenges against Doge have impeded the administration’s efforts to streamline the federal workforce, prompting a judicial examination of Musk’s involvement.
In a series of legal battles, Doge faces uncertain ground as a judge raises questions that could potentially threaten the future of the emerging agency. Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly, while refraining from making a definitive ruling during a recent hearing, voiced apprehensions regarding Doge’s constitutionality. She pointed out potential conflicts with the appointment clause of the US Constitution, which outlines the nomination process for agency leaders.
“It does raise an issue if individuals without proper authorization are carrying out certain functions,” Judge Kollar-Kotelly remarked. “Clarity is essential regarding who holds the position of administrator, acting administrator, and the extent of their authority.”
Concerns have been raised by experts over Elon Musk’s role, which appears to deviate from the traditional definition of a “special government employee” governed by specific regulations. Despite assertions from the White House that Musk complies with federal laws as a special government employee, skepticism remains among scholars. William Resh, a professor specializing in the executive branch at the University of Southern California, highlighted that Musk’s advisory role lacks the executive power associated with Senate-confirmed or presidential appointees.
Musk’s assertive actions within the federal workforce faced resistance when he demanded employees to list accomplishments in an email, sparking pushback from agency leaders appointed by former President Trump. The directive, initially mandatory, was later revised to optional due to concerns over potential disclosure of sensitive information and violations of federal guidelines.
Amidst these developments, questions arise regarding the dynamics between Doge and other administration officials under the Trump administration. Despite apparent tensions, spokesperson Leavitt emphasized unity among all members working collaboratively under President Trump’s guidance.
For the latest insights on President Trump’s second term, stay informed with North America correspondent Anthony Zurcher’s weekly newsletter, US Politics Unspun. Sign up for readers in the UK or internationally to delve into the intricacies of the evolving political landscape.
