Family Criticizes Sentence for Woman Convicted in Borders Crash
The sentencing of Angela Hislop, a 48-year-old nurse found guilty of causing the death of Janette Davidson in a two-car crash near Floors Castle in November 2022, has sparked criticism from the victim’s family. Hislop received a year-long driving ban and a 12-month nighttime curfew at her home in Kelso following a trial at Jedburgh Sheriff Court.
Relatives of 72-year-old Janette Davidson, also from Kelso, expressed disappointment in the sentencing, deeming it “far too lenient.” In a statement, the family conveyed their belief that the punishment did not adequately reflect their pain, the value of Janette’s life, or serve as a deterrent to others.
During the trial, it was revealed that Hislop had been returning from a long shift at Borders General Hospital when her car collided with Davidson’s vehicle, resulting in the tragic death of the grandmother. Despite denying feeling tired, Hislop’s Mercedes crossed into the opposite lane, striking Davidson’s car.
Sheriff Peter Paterson, presiding over the case at Selkirk Sheriff Court, acknowledged the tragic loss experienced by the victim’s family, emphasizing that no sentence could alleviate their grief. While a custodial sentence was a possibility, Sheriff Paterson opted for a 12-month night curfew and a driving ban for Hislop.
In response to the sentencing, a statement released by lawyers representing Davidson’s family highlighted the ongoing pain of losing Janette and the missed milestones that followed her passing. The family expressed disappointment in what they perceived as an inadequate outcome, emphasizing the need for justice that truly reflects the impact of the loss.
As the family continues to mourn the absence of their beloved Janette, they emphasized their commitment to moving forward with positivity and resilience, guided by the values she embodied throughout her life. Acknowledging the support they have received, the family requested privacy as they navigate their journey of healing and remembrance.
The case serves as a reminder of the devastating consequences of careless driving and the enduring impact on those left behind. It underscores the importance of accountability and justice that resonates with the true value of a life lost. The family’s call for a more meaningful sentence stands as a plea for a legal system that honors the memory of victims and upholds the responsibility of all individuals on the road.
The tragedy that unfolded on that fateful day near Floors Castle serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the repercussions of a single moment of negligence. As the legal process unfolds, the echoes of Janette Davidson’s absence reverberate through her family and community, a poignant reminder of the profound loss incurred by a preventable tragedy.
In the aftermath of the court’s decision, the family of Janette Davidson grapples with the ongoing impact of her absence, seeking solace in cherished memories and the enduring legacy of her kindness and love. Their quest for justice reflects a universal desire for accountability
