Protein powders intended for muscle mass enhancement may harbor harmful heavy metals such as cadmium and lead. A recent report by the Clean Label Project, published on January 9th, revealed that organic protein powders often exhibit significantly higher levels of toxicity. The study identified that 77% of plant-based protein powders, 79% of organic protein powders, and 65% of chocolate-flavored protein powders exceeded California Proposition 65 safety standards for toxic metals.
“The findings of the study underscore the presence of elevated levels of contaminants in many products within the health-conscious market, a fact not adequately reflected in conventional nutrition labels,” stated the report. The investigation analyzed 160 products from 70 leading protein powder brands, constituting 83% of the market, although specific brands and products were not disclosed in the report.
Protein powders derived from plant sources like rice, peas, or soy were found to contain three times the amount of lead compared to whey-based products, which originate from the liquid residue of cheese production, as reported by the study. The contamination is suspected to stem from detrimental agricultural techniques, including certain pesticides and fertilizers, in addition to packaging or environmental exposure. Heavy metals are naturally present in the Earth’s crust, absorbed by plants through their roots.
Moreover, the report highlighted that chocolate flavoring substantially contributes to the levels of toxicity. Despite the numerous health benefits associated with dark chocolate, a study conducted in July 2024 revealed that it can harbor elevated levels of heavy metals. “Chocolate-flavored protein powders were found to contain four times more lead and up to 110 times more cadmium than vanilla-flavored variants,” noted Jaclyn Bowen, the executive director of the Clean Label Project.
The Clean Label Project aims to foster more open discussions between consumers and manufacturers, promoting transparency in the procurement of health products and foods. “Given the absence of comprehensive federal regulations addressing heavy metals in dietary supplements, it is imperative for the industry to proactively implement measures independently,” the report emphasized.
The revelations regarding potentially harmful heavy metals in protein powders serve as a cautionary tale for consumers seeking to optimize their health and fitness regimens. Awareness of the presence of these contaminants underscores the importance of thorough research and scrutiny when selecting dietary supplements.
For those interested in staying informed on essential news stories, signing up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter is recommended to access a wide range of content, from celebrity updates to compelling human-interest narratives.
